Synology DS2411+ Performance Review

In my last post I compared the performance of  Synology DS1511+ against the QNAP TS-859 Pro. As I finished writing that post, Synology announced the new Synology DS2411+.
Instead of using a DS1511+ and DX510 extender for 10 disks, the DS2411+ offers 12 disks in a single device. The price difference is also marginal, DS1511+ is $836, the DX510 is $500, and the DS2411+ is $1700. That is a difference of only $364, and well worth it for the extra storage space, and the reliability and stability of all drives in one enclosure. I ended up returning my DX510 and DS1511+, and got a DS2411+ instead.

To test the DS2411+, I ran the same performance tests, using the same MPIO setup as I described in my previous post. The only slight difference was in the way I configured the iSCSI LUN; the DS1511+ was configured as SHR2, while the DS2411+ was configured as RAID6. Theoretically both are the same when all the disks are the same size, and SHR2 ends up using RAID6 internally.
iSCSI LUN configuration:
DS2411.iSCSI.LUN

At idle the DS2411+ used 42W power, and under load it used 138W power. The idle power usage is close to the advertised 39W idle power usage, but quite a bit more than the advertised 105W power usage under load.

I use Remote Desktop Manager to manage all my devices in one convenient application. RDM supports web portals, Remote Desktop, Hyper-V, and many more remote configuration options, all in a single tabbed UI. What I found was that the Synology DSM has some problems when running in a tabbed IE browser. When I open the log history, I get a script error, and whenever I focus away and back on the browser window, the DSM desktop windows shift all the way to the left. I assume this is a DSM problem related to absolute and relative referencing. I logged a support case, and I hope they can fix it.
Script error:
DS2411.DSM.Script.Error

Test results:

Device
ATTO Read
ATTO Write
CDM Read
CDM Write
PM810 267.153 260.839 256.674 251.850
DS2411+ 244.032 165.564 149.802 156.673
DS1511+ 244.032 126.030 141.213 115.032
TS-859 Pro 136.178 95.152 116.015 91.097

Chart
DS2411+:
Atto.Synology.MPIOCDM.Synology.MPIO
DS1511+
Atto.Synology.MPIOCDM.Synology.MPIO

The DS2411+ published performance numbers are slightly better than the DS1511+ numbers, and my testing confirms that. so far I am really impressed with the DS2411+.

1 Comment

  1. Peter,I was wondering if there have been any developments (other than your post) concerning the Streamload/Mediamax fiasco? I lost a lot of files that I would STILL like to get back. I am sure that others would too. Thanks!

    Like

Leave a Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.